The federal authorities has entrusted certainly one of Canada’s largest purveyors of fossil fuels to run an enormous public program to scale back demand for its personal product.
Beginning Jan. 1, Enbridge Fuel shall be taking up the Greener Properties Grant from Pure Sources Canada (NRCan) in Ontario. A giant a part of the federal government’s plan to combat local weather change, this system provides householders grants value as a lot as $5,000 for renovation initiatives to make their homes extra vitality environment friendly.
Enbridge and the federal government say the brand new program shall be extra accessible and simpler, offering householders with a one-stop store for as a lot as $10,000 from a number of such subsidies that they beforehand needed to apply for individually.
Filings with the OEB, in the meantime, reveal how the corporate tried and didn’t lengthen subsidies for brand spanking new pure gasoline furnaces and water heaters that “could have little to no influence on pure gasoline or greenhouse gasoline emissions reductions.”
Enbridge sells pure gasoline, which is generally made up of methane, a very potent greenhouse gasoline that causes 80 instances extra warming than carbon dioxide over a 20-year interval, in accordance with the UN.
The Greener Properties Grant was designed to decrease greenhouse gasoline emissions from residential buildings, the overwhelming majority of which come from pure gasoline heating.
“That is like getting the fox to protect the henhouse,” stated Kent Elson, an environmental lawyer who argued in entrance of the Ontario Vitality Board (OEB) in opposition to Enbridge’s new position.
“Enbridge desires as many individuals to make use of as a lot pure gasoline as doable, which is solely opposite to the aim of this system.”
Whereas pure gasoline has been touted as a cleaner “bridge gas,” current research have proven that emissions from pure gasoline have been underestimated resulting from widespread leaks within the extraction course of, pipeline community and connections to households. When these “fugitive emissions” are factored in, pure gasoline is simply as unhealthy for local weather change as coal, in accordance with The Atmospheric Fund.
The federal authorities has struggled to implement sturdy and efficient measures to scale back the greenhouse gasoline emissions which are driving local weather change whereas sustaining a big oil and gasoline sector that employs greater than 400,000 folks and contributes greater than $100 billion yearly to the economic system. Whereas some insurance policies to encourage adoption of low emission applied sciences, comparable to electrical autos, have discovered success, the federal government has had extra bother growing methods to cap and scale back emissions from the fossil gas business.
Over the subsequent 5 years, Enbridge shall be given $34.4 million to manage the Greener Properties Grant in Ontario for the federal authorities, which has earmarked nearly $580 million for this system. Enbridge has budgeted contributing an extra $118 million for the grants, to be taken from gas-distribution fees that it collects from clients and is required to make use of for energy-efficiency packages.
An NRCan spokesperson stated the Ontario authorities recommended they accomplice with Enbridge as a result of the corporate was already working the same provincial vitality effectivity program and “will present householders a easy, singular path to optimize vitality financial savings of their houses.”
“Co-delivery gives the chance for Enbridge Fuel and NRCan to drive stronger program outcomes extra cheaply for Ontario vitality customers than could possibly be achieved with out a co-ordinated strategy,” stated Keean Nembhard, a spokesperson for Pure Sources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson.
Enbridge spokesperson Krista Luxton added that “This strategy will keep away from house owner confusion which will inhibit or delay selections to reinforce vitality conservation.”
“Conservation packages are just one device that Enbridge Fuel is utilizing to assist the transfer to a internet zero emissions vitality future,” Luxton stated in a press release. “We’re additionally investing in and advancing a lot of new enterprise initiatives together with hydrogen, renewable pure gasoline (RNG), geothermal and hybrid heating initiatives, and wind and photo voltaic as our business strikes by way of the vitality transition.”
The brand new mixed grant program gives extra money for renovations and can make it simpler for householders to chop their carbon emissions and save on their vitality payments, says Elson. That’s because of the OEB, which final month accepted the NRCan-Enbridge deal, however overturned a number of circumstances Enbridge had positioned on the subsidies.
Had Enbridge received its method, householders who went above and past of their renovations and stopped utilizing pure gasoline solely — switching to all-electric area and water heating, cooking and garments drying — would have been prevented from getting the complete $10,000 grant.
In keeping with the OEB choice, Enbridge had argued that the vitality effectivity packages it administers are supposed to learn pure gasoline clients, and increasing the scope to incorporate individuals who lower off their gasoline was procedurally unfair with out a fuller evaluation of the monetary impacts of the misplaced clients.
The OEB disagreed, writing that “it’s of the view that this constitutes an pointless barrier towards maximizing the chance for a buyer to optimize the effectivity of their houses and maximize the discount of their GHG emissions.”
“The OEB actually did its job,” stated Elson. “Now there’s extra funding for folks to get off gasoline.”
The OEB eliminated the requirement that householders preserve their pure gasoline accounts, had Enbridge nearly double its portion of funding for the renovation grants to $60 million per 12 months and blocked the corporate from paying out grants for brand spanking new pure gasoline burning gear.
It additionally elevated the subsidy obtainable for electrical warmth pumps from $5,000 to $6,500, making it extra reasonably priced for folks to swap from a pure gasoline furnace, which not solely dramatically reduces the carbon emissions from heating, but additionally gives air con in the summertime.
/https://www.thestar.com/content/dam/thestar/columnist_logos/Oved_Marco_logo2015.JPG){kind=logo}
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Anybody can learn Conversations, however to contribute, you have to be a registered Torstar account holder. If you don’t but have a Torstar account, you may create one now (it’s free)
