Opinion: It’s no wonder nurses are leaving Quebec’s public system

Article content material

With August upon us and 6 ERs in Quebec partially closed, the federal government appears to be left scratching its head as to why we’re on this mess within the first place. Whereas Well being Minister Christian Dubé says he needs nurses to see {that a} public hospital is an “employeur de choix,” he seems to have didn’t show his level. This summer time has, to this point, been a staggering failure.

Article content material

As of late June, an estimated 60,000 health-care staff had been absent from the community for an array of causes — virtually 8,000 greater than final 12 months — and it’s secure to say that a few of them are nurses on stress depart or taking an unpaid depart of absence.

Compounding the issue is that many nurses have stop the general public sector to both change careers or work for personal companies, although numbers should not available.

Why, one may ask, would a nurse depart a authorities, unionized job with a reasonably good pension at retirement?

Regardless of having a reasonably sturdy union, nurses are nonetheless systematically abused within the office.

Before everything, there is no such thing as a cap on the variety of sufferers a nurse can have on any given shift. If there are solely 5 nurses for 50 sufferers in an ER, we in some way need to make it work. Our solely recourse is a sit-in, or an unlawful strike, for which we might be sanctioned. Making it work means lacking our breaks and slicing corners within the care we give to sufferers. Sure, it is extremely doable that some sufferers have died or will die in consequence.

Article content material

Second, even with a union, we’re nonetheless subjected to compelled and/or coerced additional time. It’s not enjoyable for a single mom to need to do an surprising double shift. Mix these two abuses with poorly thought up scheduling, archaic charting and software program within the office (the software program I exploit the place I work is from 1989 and doesn’t even assist a mouse), an excessive amount of time doing secretarial work with papers and fax machines despite the fact that everybody has a smartphone and it’s 2022, an absence of any type of assist system, and a basic ignorance by managers regarding nurses’ issues over affected person security (sure, it is extremely unsafe for sufferers if a nurse has 10 as a substitute of 5), and it’s no marvel so many have left the system.

As a substitute of scratching his head and shutting ERs, Dubé ought to put an finish to the abuse we nurses are subjected to.

Article content material

If he put a cap on the utmost variety of sufferers a nurse may have throughout her shift, we’d not really feel abused. In fact, the argument in opposition to mandated nurse-to-patient ratios is “we don’t have sufficient nurses to try this.” I might counter that with the concept that nurses would discover their jobs much more agreeable in the event that they knew they’d get a break and wouldn’t have to chop corners. Extra would keep in hospitals, nursing college students would see that as properly, and extra would come to the bedside.

Compelled additional time needs to be unlawful. Once more, the argument in opposition to making it unlawful for a supervisor to impose compelled additional time is “typically there is no such thing as a different selection.” I might counter that with the concept that managers typically are themselves nurses! Why ought to they drive a nurse to do a double shift in opposition to her will whereas they’re at dwelling sleeping? In our bureaucratic system there is not only one nurse supervisor for a selected hospital, however often three or 4! These people ought to assist out on the models if want be.

If nurses felt supported by their managers, if they’d respectable software program within the office, in the event that they had been listened to and brought significantly, then maybe so many wouldn’t have left or be absent, and people contemplating leaving would keep within the public system, the place they’re so desperately wanted.

Nathan Friedland RN works in a Montreal-area emergency room.