Howard Levitt: Workplace vaccine mandates get another boost


Follows related rulings in different jurisdictions

Article content material

Howard Levitt and Eduard Matei 

Commercial 2

Article content material

In a landmark first determination in Canada, with many prone to comply with, the B.C. Supreme Court docket has thought-about the query of whether or not an worker’s refusal to adjust to their employer’s vaccination coverage quantities to a constructive dismissal. In Parmar v Tribe Administration Inc., Justice Heather MacNaughton discovered it didn’t, that means staff selecting to not adjust to their employer’s coverage might discover themselves bereft of employment, severance and the flexibility to entry employment insurance coverage. 

Article content material

What’s constructive dismissal? 

To start with, constructive dismissal entails circumstances the place an employer modifications an worker’s phrases of labor. There’s something of a sliding scale concerned in assembly the definition, however the place the court docket finds that the modifications are substantial sufficient to warrant it, it’ll deal with an worker’s resignation from that job as in the event that they have been terminated with out trigger. A discovering of constructive dismissal brings with it all the liabilities on the employer related to such a termination, together with cost of discover, severance and wrongful dismissal damages to the previous worker. The place no constructive dismissal is discovered, the resignation is handled as simply that, disentitling the worker to note, severance and employment insurance coverage. 

Commercial 3

Article content material

The tough half is assessing how a lot of a change is critical to tip this scale. In a post-COVID-19 world beset with all the modifications the pandemic has wrought, the query of whether or not an worker’s curiosity in remaining unvaccinated trumps their employer’s curiosity in curating a protected working atmosphere has been debated, however we’ve all the time held in these pages and to our shoppers that the courts will favour employers’ selections within the curiosity of their staff’ well being. In different phrases, that requiring obligatory vaccinations to attend the office in most cases will probably be held to be authorized and refusing to vaccinate trigger for a minimum of an unpaid layoff. 

What occurred right here? 

Deepak Parmar, the worker on this case, was placed on a go away of absence by the employer, a supplier of condominium administration companies, for not complying with Tribe’s obligatory vaccination coverage. The coverage was enacted in November 2021 when the corporate sought to return to in-office operations following vital declines in productiveness in a distant mannequin tried through the opening act of COVID-19. Parmar was one in every of simply two staff — out of greater than 200  — who didn’t comply.  

Commercial 4

Article content material

Following current case legislation, the court docket accepted that COVID-19 was a doubtlessly lethal virus and simply transmissible, and that vaccines have been efficient in decreasing the severity of signs and unhealthy outcomes, even when they didn’t stop an infection, reinfection or transmission. 

On this foundation, Justice MacNaughton weighed Parmar’s private beliefs and anecdotal damaging vaccine experiences in opposition to the coverage. The query earlier than the court docket was finally whether or not this compelled go away of absence by the employer amounted to a constructive dismissal. 

The court docket framed the problem as a tough alternative for Parmar: to vaccinate and proceed her employment, or to not vaccinate and finish it. It was Parmar’s determination to not comply with a persistently enforced coverage put in place for the security of the employer’s operations, and consequently her determination to not proceed working there. Briefly, the court docket discovered no constructive dismissal. Parmar’s resignation was simply that, a resignation. The logic of this determination would additionally imply that an worker who was fired or positioned on an unpaid go away of absence for refusing to vaccinate would equally haven’t any recourse.  

Commercial 5

Article content material

What does this imply?

For workers, this determination implies that refusing to comply with insurance policies by the employer on the idea of private perception, won’t end in a optimistic final result.  

Nonetheless, it doesn’t imply that each one coverage mandates carried out by an employer are affordable, and it doesn’t imply that you simply wouldn’t have any grounds for exclusions from these insurance policies.  

For employers, this determination provides some assurance that correctly carried out and persistently enforced vaccination insurance policies aren’t prone to result in liabilities owed to those that refuse to conform. 

It is very important observe, nevertheless, that this determination doesn’t create a proper for employers to implement any coverage (whether or not vaccine or in any other case) with an accompanying carte blanche to let staff go with out legal responsibility the place it’s not adopted. The place, for instance, staff work totally from residence and haven’t any demonstrated must attend the workplace, a court docket might not discover such invasive insurance policies meet the requisite threshold. 

Commercial 6

Article content material

Not solely should the scope and impact of insurance policies be rigorously thought-about, however they should be persistently enforced. Had the employer not adopted these tenets, Parmar might nicely have succeeded. 

For the legislation, this determination is the final in a reasonably constant line of Canadian jurisprudence.  

Justice MacNaughton was removed from the primary decide to just accept the hazard of COVID-19 and the utility of vaccines. In Costa et al v Seneca School, a case determined final month wherein our agency acted on behalf of Seneca, the court docket thought-about and weighed scientific proof on the matter. It finally resulted within the dismissal of an utility to require Seneca to allow unvaccinated college students to attend campus.  

Commercial 7

Article content material

It additionally follows a parallel trajectory in creating case legislation as in Alberta in Benke v Loblaw Firms Restricted, the place the court docket discovered that non-adherence to a masks coverage equally didn’t represent a constructive dismissal, and was handled as a resignation as a substitute. 

Whereas vital uncertainty on particular situations nonetheless stays, the authorized aim posts as regards to COVID-19 employment points look like lastly coming into focus. That being stated, Parmar is at the moment making ready to attraction the choice, that means there’s nonetheless a slight probability they might shift once more. 

Howard Levitt is senior associate of Levitt Sheikh, employment and labour legal professionals with places of work in Toronto and Hamilton. He practices employment legislation in eight provinces. He’s the creator of six books together with the Legislation of Dismissal in Canada. Eduard Matei is with Levitt Sheikh. 

In case you appreciated this story, join extra within the FP Work e-newsletter.



Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in the event you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra info and particulars on find out how to modify your electronic mail settings.

Share post:


More like this

US President Joe Biden announces Indigenous spending increase | Indigenous Rights News

President Joe Biden has introduced plans to enhance...

Motocross rider dies in crash south of Brisbane

A younger motocross rider has been killed in...

Man found dead on Dorval street had criminal record

Article content material The Montreal police have...

Kourtney Kardashian holds hands with husband Travis Barker as they leave his recording studio

Kourtney Kardashian and her husband Travis Barker placed...